Your Argument Is Invalid

Random blatherings about life, the universe and everything.

293 notes


[Please Watch/Listen & Signal Boost] Man Arrested While Picking Up His Kids: ‘The Problem Is I’m Black’ | The Atlantic 

If you’ve never experienced arbitrary harassment or brutality at the hands of a police officer, or seen law enforcement act in a way that defies credulity and common sense, it can be hard to believe people who tell stories of inexplicable persecution. As I noted in “Video Killed Trust in Police Officers,” the dawn of cheap recording technology has exposed an ugly side of U.S. law enforcement that a majority of people in middle-class neighborhoods never would’ve seen otherwise. 

Today, what’s most disheartening isn’t that so many Americans still reflexively doubt stories of police harassment, as awful as it is whenever real victims are ignored. What vexes me most is police officers caught acting badly on camera who suffer no consequences and are defended by the police agencies that employ them. 

The latest example of abusive, atrocious police work posted to YouTube comes from St. Paul, Minnesota, where a black father, Chris Lollie, reportedly got off work at Cossetta, an upscale Italian eatery, walked to the downtown building that houses New Horizon Academy, where he was to to pick up his kids, and killed the ten minutes until they’d be released sitting down on a chair in a skyway between buildings. Those details come from the Minneapolis City Pageswhere commenters describe the area he inhabited as a public thoroughfare between commercial buildings. If you’re 27 and black with dreadlocks, sometimes you’re waiting to pick up your kids and someone calls the cops to get rid of you. The police report indicates a call about “an uncooperative male refusing to leave,” which makes it sound as though someone else first asked him to vacate where he was; another press report says that he was sitting in a chair in a public area when a security guard approached and told him to leave as the area was reserved for employees. The Minnesota Star Tribune visited the seating area and reported that ”there was no signage in the area indicating that it was reserved for employees.” 

So a man waiting to pick up his kids from school sits for a few minutes in a seating area where he reasonably thinks he has a right to be, private security asks him to leave, he thinks they’re harassing him because he’s black, and they call police. This is where the video begins, and that conflict is already over. The man is walking away from it and toward the nearby school where he is to pick up his kids.

So problem solved? It could have been.

Instead, this happened: [See Video Above]

What the video shows is a man who is politely but firmly telling a police officer that she has no right to ask him for identification, because he hasn’t done anything wrong or broken any laws, and is present in the building to pick up his kids. “What’s the problem?” he asks at one point, and answers his own question: “The problem is I’m black.” We can’t see inside the heads of the people who called the police or the officers who showed up, but that seems like a highly relevant factor–it certainly wasn’t unreasonable for him to reach that conclusion. 

His story about getting his kids wasn’t merely plausible, given the man’s age and the fact that there was a school right there–it was a story the female police officer shown at the beginning of the video or the male officer shown later could easily confirm. 

Lollie is also absolutely correct that no law required him to show an ID to police officers. As Flex Your Rights explains, “Police can never compel you to identify yourself without reasonable suspicion to believe you’re involved in illegal activity,” and while 24 states have passed “stop and identify” statutes “requiring citizens to reveal their identity when officers have reasonable suspicion to believe criminal activity may be taking place,” Minnesota isn’t one of those states.

Filed under minnesota i am so disappointed police tw racial profiling

82,077 notes


NASA astronaut films lightning from ISS

Astronaut Reid Wiseman posted a Vine from the International Space Station today showing lightning over Houston.

Tornado warnings were issued in the Houston area earlier this afternoon but have since expired.

Filed under weather

61 notes


Discovering the Fascinating Past of 1421 5th St. NE

A few years ago I lived down the block from a house with one odd architectural feature: above the doorway was a large piece of stone with “MRS A H WALSTEN - AD 1900” carved into it. I’d always wondered who exactly Mrs. A. H. Walsten was — the sort of person who carves their name into stone usually seems like the sort of person with a good story behind them. I decided to do a little digging this summer.

My first step was to look at the old building permit card for the house (formerly 1427 5th St. NE, now 1421 5th St. NE). It referenced a “Hannah Walsten” which gave me more of a name to go off of. Next I took a look at the digitized city directories to see if I could find any listings by that name. I found a reference to an “August Walsten” living there in 1900 and a “Mrs. Hannah M Walsten, midwife” living there in 1901 but not much else by that specific name. Next I decided to try a slightly different resource: the digitized issues of the Minneapolis Journal from the early 1900s. Maybe I could find a reference to their marriage? Or a real estate transaction for the house?

I ended up coming across much more than I anticipated! It turns out Mrs. Hannah Walsten had gone by five different names and been married to four different men (including August H. Walsten on two separate occasions). This came to light when she was arrested for performing a “criminal operation” (an abortion). She had been running what was referred to at the time as a “baby farm” (essentially an unlicensed orphanage) out of her home.

The old Minneapolis Journal had multiple stories detailing her trial and the various dramatic scenes which unfolded in court. She was ultimately found guilty — one story said she was the first woman to be successfully convicted of performing an abortion in Hennepin County — and sentenced to 28 months in Stillwater Prison.


This post was researched and written by Special Collections volunteer Nick Steffel. Photos of the house were taken by Nick.

(via stuffaboutminneapolis)

Filed under tw: abortion history minneapolis minnesota